What are differences between Anna Sewell's Black Beauty and the movie?

Films always need much more visual and emotional drama to be appealing to viewers than books need to be appealing to readers. As such, while director Caroline Thompson's 1994 film is the most accurate adaptation of Anna Sewell's Black Beauty available, there are some differences.In films, conflicts and love intrigues must be established early on. For this reason, in the film, Black Beauty falls in lovewith Ginger early in the story, but...

Films always need much more visual and emotional drama to be appealing to viewers than books need to be appealing to readers. As such, while director Caroline Thompson's 1994 film is the most accurate adaptation of Anna Sewell's Black Beauty available, there are some differences.

In films, conflicts and love intrigues must be established early on. For this reason, in the film, Black Beauty falls in love with Ginger early in the story, but Ginger refuses to be friendly. In contrast, in the book, though Ginger is hostile towards Beauty upon his arrival because she accuses him of usurping her of ownership rights to the lose box, they warm up to each other fairly quickly. When first partnered with Ginger in the carriage, Beauty notes that Ginger "behaved very well," and he developed an admiration for her to the extent that he declares, "I never wish to have a better partner in double harness" (Ch. 5). And by the seventh chapter, Beauty and Ginger are friendly enough that she shares with him her life story. However, though they are friendly, they don't develop what can be considered a romance until they are both ruined by foolish drivers at Earlshall Park. Both are put in a meadow on Earlshall Park to regain their strength and greatly enjoy each other's company. Beauty describes what can be interpreted as spending romantic time with each other in the following:

We both felt in ourselves that we were not what we had been. However, that did not spoil the pleasure we had in each other's company; we did not gallop about as we once did, but we used to feed, and lie down together, and stand for hours under one of the shady lime-trees with our heads close to each other. (Ch.27)

To add more action, director Thompson created another difference by slightly changing the scene in which Beauty is being driven in a storm. In chapter 12, Beauty is out with Squire Gordon and John Manley on a business trip during a stormy day. By the end of the day, the storm is much worse. After being nearly struck and blocked by a falling branch, John turns the dog-cart around to take the other route across the bridge. But, Beauty refuses to cross the bridge because he senses it has been damaged by the storm. Soon enough, the man at the toll-gate informs them the bridge is broken in the middle. Prior to learning the bridge is broken, John jumps out of the dog-cart and goes to Beauty's head to see what is the matter. Upon learning the bridge is broken, John thanks God and praises Beauty then turns him around to pursue a different path. In contrast, in the film, John jumps out to try to pull Beauty across the bridge. Then, the bridge actually collapses, making John lose his footing. John saves himself by holding on to Beauty's bridle and is pulled to safety by Squire Gordon. In the book, John is much smarter than in the film because he knows to trust the instincts of a horse for sensing danger.